Article Contents
In this difficult economic period, there are many business owners that are not able to produce enough income to pay their mortgage. If you find yourself in this unfortunate dilemma, you may be faced with commercial foreclosure. In Florida, commercial property owners facing foreclosure have several legal options for defense. These defenses can help delay the foreclosure process, provide leverage for negotiations, or potentially result in a dismissal of the foreclosure action.
Understanding the Foreclosure Process in Florida
The process begins when the borrower defaults on the mortgage loan, typically by missing one or more payments. Other types of default may include failing to pay property taxes or maintain insurance on the property. The lender sends a Notice of Default to the borrower, informing them of the missed payments and the amount needed to cure the default. This notice may also include a deadline by which the borrower must pay the overdue amount to avoid further action. If the borrower does not cure the default within the specified period, the lender may accelerate the debt. This means that the entire loan balance becomes due and payable immediately.
The lender files a foreclosure complaint in the appropriate circuit court. This legal action initiates the foreclosure process. The complaint outlines the details of the loan, the default, and the lender’s intent to foreclose on the property. The lender must properly serve the borrower with the foreclosure complaint and a summons. The borrower typically has 20 days to respond to the complaint. The borrower can file a response to the foreclosure complaint, raising any defenses or counterclaims they may have. This step is critical, as failing to respond can result in a default judgment in favor of the lender.
Both parties engage in the discovery process, exchanging documents and information relevant to the case. Pretrial motions may be filed to resolve specific legal issues before the trial. The lender may file a motion for summary judgment if they believe there are no material facts in dispute and they are entitled to judgment as a matter of law. If the court grants this motion, the foreclosure will proceed without a trial. If summary judgment is denied, the case goes to trial. The court will hear evidence from both parties and make a determination on the foreclosure. If the court rules in favor of the lender, a final judgment of foreclosure is entered. This judgment includes the total amount owed by the borrower, including the principal balance, interest, fees, and costs.
The property is scheduled for a public auction, typically conducted by the County Clerk. The sale must be advertised for at least two consecutive weeks before the auction date. At the auction, the property is sold to the highest bidder. The proceeds are used to pay off the foreclosure judgment. If the sale amount is less than the amount owed, the lender may seek a deficiency judgment against the borrower for the remaining balance. In Florida, borrowers do not have a statutory right of redemption after the foreclosure sale. However, they can redeem the property before the sale by paying the total amount due, including all fees and costs.
Challenging the Lender's Legal Standing
Challenging the lender's legal standing is a critical defense strategy in commercial foreclosure cases. This defense questions whether the lender has the legal right to foreclose on the property. The lender must demonstrate that they are the rightful owner of the loan. This involves proving that they possess the original promissory note or a validly endorsed copy. If the loan has been transferred or sold, the lender must provide a clear chain of title showing all assignments and endorsements. If the mortgage has been assigned from the original lender to another entity, the assignment must be properly executed and recorded. Any irregularities or gaps in the assignment chain can be grounds for challenging the lender's standing.
MERS (mortgage electronic registration systems) is often used to track mortgage transfers. If MERS is involved, the borrower can challenge whether MERS has the authority to act on behalf of the lender. Courts have varied in their rulings on MERS' standing to foreclose, making this a potential area of challenge.
Many commercial loans are securitized, meaning they are bundled with other loans and sold to investors as mortgage-backed securities. Borrowers can challenge whether the entity attempting to foreclose is the proper party if the loan was securitized. The lender must show that the loan is part of the securitization trust and that they have the authority to enforce the loan. Also, borrowers can challenge the lender’s standing by investigating whether documents were improperly signed or notarized. "Robo-signing" refers to the practice of bank employees signing documents without verifying their accuracy. Evidence of robo-signing can undermine the lender's case.
Negotiating a Loan Modification
A loan modification involves changing the terms of the existing loan to make it more manageable for the borrower, potentially avoiding foreclosure. Negotiating a loan modification can provide a borrower with a number of potential outcomes, including lowering the interest rate, extending the loan term, principal forbearance, and a reduction in principal. These outcomes could possibly help a borrower avoid foreclosure, lower their monthly payments, and improve their financial stability.
Defending Against a Deficiency Judgment
A deficiency judgment is a court order that makes the borrower personally liable for the difference between the foreclosure sale price of the property and the outstanding loan balance. Defending against a deficiency judgment is a crucial aspect of commercial foreclosure defense for property owners.
In Florida, lenders can seek a deficiency judgment if the proceeds from the foreclosure sale are insufficient to cover the outstanding mortgage debt. Deficiency judgments can apply to both residential and commercial properties, though the process and defenses may differ.
Florida law provides certain statutory defenses against deficiency judgments. The lender must file for a deficiency judgment within one year after the foreclosure sale. While Florida does not have anti-deficiency statutes for commercial properties, it's important to verify if any recent legislative changes or case law may impact the lender’s ability to pursue a deficiency.
Defending against a deficiency judgment requires a thorough understanding of the foreclosure process, valuation of the property, and applicable legal defenses. By scrutinizing the foreclosure sale, challenging the lender’s calculations, and exploring both statutory and equitable defenses, Florida property owners can effectively defend against deficiency judgments. Legal representation is essential to ensure that all potential defenses are fully explored and presented.
Seeking Alternative Resolutions Through Mediation
Mediation is a voluntary, confidential process where a neutral third-party mediator facilitates negotiations between the borrower and the lender. The mediator does not make decisions but helps both parties communicate effectively and explore possible resolutions. Mediation can prevent the foreclosure case from proceeding to court, saving time and legal expenses. Parties can negotiate customized solutions tailored to their specific needs and circumstances. Discussions during mediation are confidential, which can encourage open communication and settlement. Plus, mediation can help maintain a positive relationship between the borrower and the lender, which may be beneficial for future interactions.
Mediation can be a highly effective way for Florida property owners to resolve commercial foreclosure disputes without the need for prolonged litigation. By preparing thoroughly, engaging in good faith negotiations, and exploring various resolution options, borrowers can often achieve outcomes that are more favorable than those obtained through the court process.
Your Legal Representation
Facing foreclosure on your commercial property can be very scary. Fortunately, there are a number of valid defenses to commercial foreclosures but you must act quickly. I’m Rob Robinson, and I can help you navigate the complex legal landscape, identify potential defenses, and represent your interests in court or negotiations. Contact my office today and let my 30+ years of practicing commercial property law help you during your difficult time.


